A Tale of Two Mittens

(I can’t believe I used that title. And I call myself a writer.)
So. Last fall I taught a class on Fair Isle knitting and used this pattern as an example. It’s knit with fingering weight, and I used a size 2.5mm needle. For all you non-knitters out there, this proves that I have the skillz, baby.
I finished one, put the whole kit and kaboodle into a bag and threw it on a shelf in my office, figuring that one day I’d finish them up.
Last week I was feeling under the weatherish and decided, with no logic, that I desperately needed to finish the mittens. Right then. Right there. So I pulled out the whole kit and kaboodle and knit up mitten two.
And at the very top I realized. Oh shit. My gauge is way off. As in, one mitten would fit me and one would fit LeBron James. (Okay. Maybe not LeBron. Maybe Tom Brady.) (By the way, no matter that he lost. Tom is still pretty.)
Warning. The remainder of this post will be uninteresting to non-knitters.
So, in a fit of frustration, I threw them back on the shelf, figuring my gauge was way off for whatever reason. Maybe it was off because I was sick (possible), or my tension had changed in four months (not nearly as possible), or I had thrown the wrong needles in the kit and kaboodle (seems unlikely).
But those mittens, oh how they haunted me. It was like they were calling me from my little office downstairs. Annnnnnnnnnnn………..Annnnnnnnnnnnnnnn…………you fail. YOU FAIL.
I couldn’t take it anymore. I hate failures in knitting, although they happen to me more often than, as a professional, I want to admit.
So I ripped out the Tom Brady mitten and started over, this time with a smaller needle. The ones in the kit and kaboodle were 2.5mm, so I went with a 2.25mm. And guess what. Still too big. I mean, what the beeeeeeeeeeeep? So now I’m casting on with the smallest of the smalls. That means. Yes, you guessed it. Dah duh DUUUUUUH! 2.0.
I know, right?
I’ll keep you posted. All none of you who read my blog.